Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (2024)

Browse the winning main dishes, sides dishes and desserts from our Best of the Midwest® recipe contests. They highlight regional flavors with fresh accents.

01of 32

Spinach-Mushroom-Sausage Pierogi Bake

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (1)

You don't get much easier than this recipe from Jan Valdez of Chicago! Saute a few ingredients, stir in cream cheese to make a sauce, and dump it all over frozen pierogis in a casserole dish. (You don't even need to thaw the pierogis!)

View Recipe

02of 32

Salted Caramel, Chocolate and Peanut Cracker-Stack Bars

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (2)

These fantastic potluck bars come from Patrice Hurd of Bemidji, Minnesota. She won the grand prize in a Best of the Midwest Recipe Contest. Patrice says they're a twist on her grandmother's cracker bars. They cut beautifully and brim with salty-sweet-nutty-chocolately flavor.

View Recipe

03of 32

Italian Dinner Soup

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (3)

Gail Gladding-Pullara of Oregon, Wisconsin, created this simple, crowd-pleasing soup. "My family loves this recipe," she says. "It's easy and tastes like you've been cooking for hours."

View Recipe

04of 32

Sticky Asian Pork Wrap

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (4)

A $1,000 winner in our annual recipe contest, this colorful sandwich from Lori McLain of Denton, Texas, is a flavor twist on a classic Midwestern tenderloin sandwich.

View Recipe

05of 32

Chocolate Hazelnut Cream Cheese Puffs

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (5)

Dawn Logterman of Verona, Wisconsin, created this clever twist on the classic cream puffs served at the Wisconsin State Fair. Her recipe was a finalist in our annual recipe contest.

View Recipe

06of 32

Milk-Braised Pork with Cheesy Grits

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (6)

There are a lot of ingredients in this spruced-up comfort-food dish, but trust us, it's worth the effort for a weekend treat. The recipe from Michael Watz of Chicago was a finalist in our Best of the Midwest® recipe contest.

View Recipe

07of 32

Cranberry-Orange Wild Rice Muffins

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (7)

This North Woods-inspired recipe from Cheryl Francke of Arden Hills, Minnesota, was a finalist in a Best of the Midwest recipe contest.

View Recipe

08of 32

Peanut Butter Buckeye Brownie Cheesecake

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (8)

Dawn Moore of Warren, Pennsylvania, grew up sampling buckeye candy from neighboring Ohio. It was the muse for this outrageously rich and creamy dessert she created.

View Recipe

09of 32

Walleye Wild Rice Cakes with Wasabi Dressing

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (9)

Cindi Rockwell of Berkley, Michigan, says this recipe, which has two signature Minnesota ingredients, was inspired by the resort her grandparents owned there.

View Recipe

10of 32

Peach Cordial Mini Bundt Cakes

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (10)

The memory of a childhood orchard trip inspired Melinsa Murphey of Olathe, Kansas, to create this recipe. The cakes are moist and sweet and quite generously proportioned, so you may want to serve a half-cake to each person (or bake them in muffin cups instead).

View Recipe

11of 32

Roasted Cherry Tomato Chutney on Squash

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (11)

Annie France of Mission, Kansas, invented this beautiful summer dish. Juicy cherry tomatoes are roasted and served over spaghetti squash with herbs and mozzarella balls. Annie says she serves it as a side dish, but we think it would make a fantastic meatless main.

View Recipe

12of 32

Very Cherry Hazelnut Coffee Cake

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (12)

David Dahlman of Chatsworth, California, says this yeasty coffee cake reminds him of the old-fashioned, down-to-earth treats on his grandmother's farm table. It takes time because it's a yeast-leavened dough, but there's no kneading required.

View Recipe

13of 32

Meat and Potato Pizza

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (13)

Chalk this recipe up as an occasional indulgence. It's topped with a totally mouth-watering combo of thin-sliced potatoes, bacon, sausage and a delectable garlic-rosemary butter. The recipe comes from Hidemi Walsh of Plainfield, Indiana.

View Recipe

14of 32

Pumpkin Chili

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (14)

This recipe, submitted by Melanie Madore of Ashland, Missouri, was a finalist in our recipe contest. Unlike many pumpkin chilis, what sets this one apart is using cubed pumpkin (or butternut squash) rather than canned.

View Recipe

15of 32

Spiced Pecan Sweet Potato Cake

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (15)

Deborah Biggs of Omaha completes this amazingly moist dessert with Maple Whipped Cream. Spiced Pecan Sweet Potato Cake

16of 32

Wisconsin Harvest Pie

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (16)

This almond-kissed, fruit-packed pie comes from David Harper, of Richland Center, Wisconsin. He likes to serve it with a wedge of Wisconsin cheese, but it's just as good with vanilla ice cream or whipped cream! The recipe was a finalist in our annual recipe contest.

Jen's White Burger

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (17)

This sandwich looks a bit plain, but appearances can be deceiving. It's packed with flavor. Mustard, herbs and lemon zest season the meat, which is topped with wine-poached pears, sharp cheddar and pepper jelly. The recipe comes from Jen Smallwood of Portsmouth, Virginia.

View Recipe

18of 32

Cranberry Sausage-Stuffed Pork Chops with Pumpkin Gravy

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (18)

This recipe from Linda Kay Drysdale of Riverview, Michigan, won the $10,000 top prize in one of our Best of the Midwest recipe contests. Linda's recipe calls for chops cooked in a pressure cooker, which reduces cooking time to a fifth of the oven version. Watching calories? Half a chop satisfies most people.

View Recipe

19of 32

Caramel and Chocolate Kettle-Corn Crispie Bars

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (19)

This recipe from Judy Reynolds of Bloomington, Indiana, was the $10,000 winner in our first Best of the Midwest cook-off. Start with a Hoosier staple-popcorn-and stir together these sweet-salty snack bars. Homemade caramel sauce helps makes them a standout.

View Recipe

20of 32

Skillet Pork and Apple Mini Meat Loaves

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (20)

Patrice Hurd of Bemidji, Minnesota, says this moist, sweet and tangy comfort food reminds her of Sunday dinner at her grandmother's in northern Minnesota. Best of all, it's fast.

View Recipe

21of 32

Orange-Laced Blueberry-Rhubarb Cobbler with Almond Biscuits

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (21)

Barbara Estabrook of Rhinelander, Wisconsin, tops a juicy base with so-tender drop biscuits tasting of almond—-from almond flour! (Purchase it online or at large supermarkets.)

View Recipe

22of 32

Kiwi Summer Limeade Pie

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (22)

Refreshing and creamy, this make-ahead pie from Susan Meier of Omaha combines tropical flavors with macadamia nuts and kiwifruit. It's good any time of year.

View Recipe

23of 32

Cider-Brined Coho Salmon with Dijon Cream

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (23)

Freshwater salmon soaks up the flavor of cider-tarragon marinade created by Sally Sibthorpe of Shelby Township, Michigan. She finishes the elegant main dish with a cream sauce scented with aniselike tarragon.

View Recipe

24of 32

Strawberry-Coconut Thumbprints

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (24)

Linda Roberts of Rapid City, South Dakota, tops her buttery cream cheese, coconut-coated cookie with fruit jam.

View Recipe

25of 32

BLT Chicken Sliders

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (25)

If you haven't embraced chicken burgers yet, this mini burger will change your mind. Barbara Estabrook of Rhinelander, Wisconsin, grills white cheddar sliders and crowns them with bacon and her cranberry ketchup.

View Recipe

26of 32

Grilled Sirloin Kabobs with Zesty Top City Sauce

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (26)

Joann Gough-Stallbaumer of Topeka uses Kansas top sirloin steak and a horseradish-mayo dipping sauce in her prizewinning recipe.

View Recipe

27of 32

Sweet and Sassy Walleye Chowder in Bread Bowls

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (27)

Linda Rohr of Darien, Connecticut, came up with a Midwest version of East Coast chowder using lake-fresh walleye, corn and sweet potato chunks in a golden bread bowl.

View Recipe

28of 32

Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (28)

The famous St. Louis dessert gets a makeover from Emily Hobbs of Springfield, Missouri. She adds pumpkin and pumpkin pie spice to the moist cake.

View Recipe

29of 32

Orange-Glazed Sweet Potato Breakfast Braid

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (29)

Cathy Wiechert of Mound, Minnesota, created a moist morning bread with a mellow blend of spices, citrus peel and raisins. It bakes to a gorgeous gold.

View Recipe

30of 32

Stuffed Cheesesteaks

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (30)

This amazing steak sandwich is the creation of Karen Gibson of Cincinnati. The unusual flavor combo? A mix that includes a little chocolate, cinnamon and allspice.

View Recipe

31of 32

The BMC 2

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (31)

This bacon-topped muffin was developed by Jill Drury of Chicago. Jill, a pharmacist, used a scientific-formula approach to name her creation based on its ingredients: bacon, maple syrup and cinnamon (squared).

32of 32

Beef Short Ribs with Cranberry-Port Gravy

Midwest Living Prizewinning Reader Recipes (32)

Short ribs slow-cook to mouthwatering tenderness in this meaty main dish spiked with cranberry sauce and rosemary. The recipe is from Diane Sparrow of Osage, Iowa.

View Recipe